HOW TO ESTIMATE INFORMATION AND CHOOSE
A PAINT BOOTH?
|
| |
We
went through a historical moment. We have made a decission to
buy a spray booth. We will form a real spray shop. We would
like our invested finance resources to have a high refund rate.
It is also important that bought devices are modern, always
efficient, safe, easy in use, have low exploit costs, assure
proper work parameters, were esthetic, etc.
How to make a proper choise if the market is full of factory
new devices offers and it is also possible to buy a second handed
devices?
Every supplier assures that delivered by him devices exactly
fulfill our expectations.
In case of cars, most of us knows what does air condition, ABS,
air bag, electricaly steering windows, pyrotechnicall seat belt
stretcher, radio, ventilation, heated back window, engine, power
engine, gearbox, turning moment, injection, turbocompressor,
intercooler, etc. mean. But when we start talking about appliances
like EDS, ASR even sellers in famous car showrooms get confused.
|
Do
we know what does a supplier say and what is the meaning of
itwhile spray booth expliotation if he use definitions, like:
air flow speed, fans efficiency,
demister system, extracting system, thermic power, T thermic
jump, thermic interia, temperature domposition, isolation, air
distribution system, ventilation system efficiency regulation,
spraying phase, drying phase, ventilation, chilling, air recilculation,
exchanger with a linear flow, exchanger with a cross flow, metal
base, concrete moat, floor bars, initial filters, ceiling filters,
floor filters, coal filter, lightning intensity, light colour,
steering, ets?
|
While buying
a car do we care what engine it will have and if we are able
easily, fast and safety to make an overtake manoeuvre on our
crowdy roads? Is it important if the car has an air condition
or a power steering?
Let us unswer the question: while making such a serious decission
is it only the price that matters or is it also important what
do we get for this price?
Remember that spray booths watched from outside hardly have
any difference and we have to make a decission if we buy it
to bring jealousy with the owners of the neighbour garage or
we buy it to assure a stable and safe working conditions for
our sprayer.
We understand that this is a very difficult decission that is
why we have prepared this guide.
|
 Before
we talk start technical topics, we would like mention the possibility
of buying second handed pain booths brought from west countires.
Could we go to the Casino and play "red" or "black"
alternatively "even" or "odd" for the abount
of about 40.000 zł? If the answer is - yes, I?. Gratulate you
a bent for gambling and rich wallet. In this case money is the
only loss. In case of the spray booth it is not only money but
sometimes also somebody's health or life. In the year 2001 there
were explisions and fires in several spray booths in Poland.
There have been tighten rules concerning spray booth work parameters
in European Union and a big amount of them is now brought to
our country.
|
Please
do remember that Poland is the country, which aspirates to be
a member of EU and weather we want it or not all Union directives
will be in force also in our country.
|
| |
WHAT PARAMETERS
CHARACTERIZE A SPRAY BOOTH? |
| |
The basic
parameter is spray booth's dimansions because they determinate
the size of vehicles. It would be difficoult to work in the
5m length spray booth if the car is 4m long. That is why most
of the spray booths have the length of 6 - 7 m and 4m width.
This width is optimal and adapted to most of vehicles.
Everybody knows that is would be more comfortable to work in
a 5m long spray booth. We should also understand that increasing
a spray booth surface will bring the increase of ventilation
system efficiency to assure a proper air
flow speed. This will also increase the use of heating
system that is neccesary to assure a proper level of thermal
jump ΔT These factors cause
the increase of exploit costs. Like you can see there are no
technical obstacles to make a long and wild spray booth but
there are high execution and exploit costs.
|
There are
no limits concerning the height of the
spray booth. The higher it can be, more comfortable it
is to work. The spray booth that is 3m high is much more comfortable
that 2,6m because it can also serve trucks and buses. Increased
height has no impact on neccesity of bringing more efficient
generator. |
The following
parameter that characterize spray booths is ventilator's
efficiency. It must be selected to achieve at least an
average value of 0,25 m/sec by a vertical
air move (air flow speed). It means that the air together
with a spray mist moves by the vertical
move up and down 25cm/sec. After placing a vehicle in
a spray booth the active spray booth surface decrease and flow
speed rise in proportion to the surface decrease. Air
flow speed depends on two factors: spray booth surface
and used ventilators efficiency. German, French or Belgian spray
booth producers use in their products exactly 0,25
m/sec flow speed and most of Italian or Spanish producers
use 0,20 m/sec flow speed. |
The problem
is with the reliability of technical
details given by producers, especially concerning ventilator's
efficiency that is different depending on achieved pressure.
Some producers give the values according to ventilators that
are working without a load that means maximum values or with
channels and filters resistance that means nominal values. |
There is
one more thing connected to the ventlator's efficiency and that
is an environmental protection. There is The
Highest Permissible Concentration of damaging substance
excreted by a spray booth. While one hour of spraying no matter
if in garage or spray booth the same amount of lacquer material
is released from the pistol. Ventilator's efficiency depend
on the level of diluting excreted dangerous and harmful substances. |
Ventiolator's
efficiency is connected to the spray booth surface, air
flow speed and also ecological and safe work of the whole spray
booth. |
Correctly
configurated spray booth must be equipped in a
separate fan system both ventilation and blow away. The
fact that in Poland 80% of spray booths have only ventilation
fan system is caused only by buyer's
unknowledge, sellers abilities and costs. |
There is
a heating system straight connected
the ventilation system. It must be selected according to the
device efficiency to assure a proper temperature
increase (thermal jump ΔT) on the same level that
the climate in assembled spray booth room. Thermal jump is an
air temperature increase and that is the difference between
the air sucked in to the spray booth (almost always form outside)
and a maximum air temperature deliviered to the inside of the
spray booth after passing a heating system. If there is winter
and the outside temperature is -15oC, and if the
optimal temeprature in tha spray booth we want to achieve is
20oC we must achieve a thermal jump on the level
of 35oC. However the heating efficiency (power) will
be different for various ventilator's
efficiency. |
Technically
it does not cause any problems. It is possible to install as
big heating system to achieve a problem thermal
jump without any difficulties. We should think if in
our climate conditions where we have about 7 days a year the
temperature below -15oCthe use of a huge heating
system is really neccesary. Maybe we should install less efficient
heating system that will not be able to work in very low temperatures
but for the rest 95% of days in a year it will work with its
full power. |
The most
profitable solution in Polosh climate is the use of the heating
system that achieve a thermal jump on the level of 26 - 27oC
connected to a special system that lets to increase temporary
ΔT to about 35oC.
This kind of solutions are used by some of famous spray booth
producers and find application in spray booths utilized in north
countries (especially Scandinavia). It is the most rational
solution of heating system efficiency. |
One of
the most important element for a proper system work is its foundation.
The best solution is so-called concrete
moat. It is a lower air flow channel adequately shaped
and with an adequate depth. It assures unlimited and even air
flow. All traders will talk about problems concerning building
this moat (made by an investor) and will suggest much easier
solution like a metal base. Because of a small height (about
300 mm) of a metal base it will be a kind of a barrier for a
proper air flow in it. Metal base is only a replacable solution
also in famous companies in places where because of technical
reasons it is not possible to make a concrete moat. In spite
of all a metal base is not so cheap.
Once again we have a chance to think why we have decided to
buy a spray booth?
|
Ważnym
parametrem jest również ilość, rozmieszczenie,
rodzaj i barwa oświetlenia. Człowiek pracujący w kabinie
lakierniczej musi mieć możliwość łatwego rozpoznawania i porównywania
barw w związku z czym powinny być zastosowane świetlówki o odpowiednio
dobranej barwie emitowanego światła,
lampy muszą mieć odpowiednią klasę ochrony jeżeli dostęp do
świetlówek odbywa się od strony wewnętrznej, dla zapewnienia
odpowiedniej jasności pomieszczenia kabiny konieczne jest zastosowanie
odpowiednio dużej ilości punktów świetlnych. |
The
quantity, place, type and colour of the lightning are
also very important elements. A person that works in a spray
booth must have a possibility of identifying and comparing colours.
That is why fluorescent light with a specially selected
colours of emitted light is neccesary. Lamps need a proper
security class if the access to the fluorescent light is from
the internal side. To ensure a proper spray booth room brightness
it is necessary to use enough amount of light points. |
 There
are two ways of placing lamps in the spray booth. First is placing
lamps on the slants between the spray booth wall and filter
ceiling. It causes a higher light intensity in a work place
and less quantity of installed lamps and fluorescent lights.
In case of installing only a ventilation system the increased
susceptability for turbulences and air whirl becomes a disadvantage.
Second way is placing a big amount of lamps in wall pannels,
mostly in two lines. This solution gives opportunity to install
ceiling filters with almost the same surface like a spray booth
surface. The disadvantage is a double amount of the fluorescent
light and much higher electricity use.
This solution gives a very good distract and high light
intensity in the spray booth.
The next question is: cheap or good? |
A middle
solution with a very good parameters is placing lamps on the
top of slants and additional vertical lamps in the corners of
the spray booth on the floor level. It gives a good intensity
in a working area and does not make a shadow on the surface
of the sprayer's shadow. All the
lights glasses must be made from the
safe glass. |
| |
HOW
SPRAY BOOTHS ARE BUILT? |
| |
A spray
booth is mostly made from pannels self-supporting construction,
isolated by different materials, like: polystyrene,
frothen poliuretan, standard or ironed mineral wool.
Imagine an expirience.
|
We put
on one table: a piece of polystyrene, poliuretan and a piece
of a mineral wool. We will play with a lighter and see what
will be the result of the play. Lets take a spoon of a solvent
used in spray booths that is a part of a lacquer and pour on
each of prepared materials. After this kind of expirience we
will already know what kind of isolation should be used in spray
booth's constructions. |
WMost of
the producers isolate only sprayh booth's walls. Famous producers
also isolate roofs or even whole generators where the air with
a temperature of 60o C. flows in a drying phase.
There are also rumours that no isolation is necessary and this
kind of spray booths arrive to Poland. Imagine a late autumn
and cold outside. In a holl shop is the temperature of 15oC
. There is a recently sprayed car in a spray booth. The temperature
inside the spray booth is 60oC. It means that the
temperature difference is 45oC. Let's unswer the
question if there is a heat penetration throught a spray booth's
wall that is made from 1 mm metal steel. |
The next
thing that have a great impact on a device efficiency is the
floor bars size under which spray-stop floor filters are placed.
There are several solutions from the worst to the best. |
Narrow
bars under a car - a little bit archaic solution in the
cheapest spray booths with a small ventilation system. A car
surface blocks an air access to the outflow channels. |
Two
narrow bars placed under car wheels - more efficient
solution because parts of bars can be seen from the car side
contour. It lets for a better air penetration to the outflow
chanel. |
Two
narrow bars placed under car wheels connected to additional
bars at the beginning and the end of the channel, so called
"RING" system - solution similar to the previous
but giving more efficient air flow also in the front and the
back of the vehicle. It increases the result of an air fall
and make a good spraying of those parts to be possible. |
Above solutions
require a central precise car placing to make an air fall to
be maximum even. This kind of solutions dominates in devices
with small efficiency ventilators (mostly one ventilator systems).
The less floor filter's sufrace is the easier and faster the
result is achieved. Regardless of the filters surface while
spraying the same amount of spray lacquer is released and that
is why the amount of particles is also constant and the small
surface filter will get easily clogged. The consequence of the
floor filter pollution is a high increase (especially in one
ventilator spray booths) of hypertension in the spray booth
that leads to air fall speed decrase.
|
If this
value increases below 0,16 m/sec
we will achieve somillar conditions to the conditionas in the
garage with opened widnows. |
A
floor grated on a big surface, mostly 5 x 3 m - very
efficient solution, deprived all above mentioned faults. |
A
floor grated in 100% - the best and the most expensive
solution because of the big amount of platform grating and neccessity
of making supports systems on which gratings are hanged. |
ATTENTION
- some of producers use two last solutions but still under grating
and filters they put metal sheet on the surface of floor grating
leaving only two narrow bars under the car wheels. This kind
of solution is caused by using small efficiency ventilators.
|
ENTERING
door to the spray booth - there are also differences
in the way of making entering door. The entrance must make an
easy entering to be possible and after closing such a sealing
that no air with harmfull and dangerous substances would get
out. There are two basic ways of making doors. First - double
wings door, second - treble wings
door. Treble wings door take less place while opening
because of the narrow door. One of the door wings works as a
service and must be equipped in a safety lock which lets to
open the door under a pressure form inside in case of any crisis
situation. When applying double wings door it is necessary to
install a separate service door. Every construction should include
circuital gasket and closing system, eg. bolting to ensure a
proper door fram tightening. It is also godd if door wings are
thermally isolated.
The maximum height and width is an advantage because it ensures
a trouble-free entering to the chamber.
|
ARE WE AWARE
OF THE SPRAY BOOTH WORK? |
| There are two basic phases of
work: spraying and drying phase. |
The way
of working in a spraying phase should be the same for the sake
of safety and efficient ventilation. An injection ventilator
take a clean air from outside and point it to the heat exchanger.
There the air is heated and pointed to the spray booth filtering
joint assembly. Then it goes through ceiling filters and penetrate
with a vertical move up and down depending on the spray booth
equipment. It can also be "squeezed" through crates
and floor filters and pushed out to the mouth ventilation channel
placed over the roof of the building (one-fan demister spray
booths). It can also be drawn in by an extracting ventilator
and pushed out through a mouth ventilation channel over its
buildings (double-fan demister extracting spray booths). The
air is deeply polluted that is why it can not be used in spray
booth heating. |
In drying
phase individual devices work in different ways. It is caused
by a neccessity of achieving much higher temperature 60-70oC.
The temperatre on the level of 70-80oC will not be
able to achieve while using a heating system with a stantard
heating efficiency. |
| What can we do about it? |
One of
the solutions would be installing a heating unit with a hudge
power but it is economically not justified. There are three
solutions to the problem right now.
The simpliest technical solution is to let only 20-25% of the
initial ventilator efficiency value to flow through the heating
exchanger. This amount of the air can be easily heated to the
demanded temperature. The disadvantage is a very irregular drying
of a vehicle. Vertical parts of the car body dry up much longer
then a horizontal parts and the process of drying may be very
long. In this solution the whole heated air is thrown to the
atmosphere.
Other solution is a mechanical limitation of the inlet channel
section that decreases the efficiency of ventilators to about
50%. Additionally there opens a cover between the inlet channel
and the heat exchanger chamber that lets to suck in some amount
of hot air through the air stream that is suck in by inlets.
The air delivered to the heat exchanger is mixed with the hot
air and that is why its temperature is much higher. It causes
that the air that flows through the heat exchanger can achieve
a proper temperature increase. Pople who are connected with
spray booths production call his solution
"a by pass". The advantage of it is delivering
much bigger of the hot air what incredibly improves and accelerates
a drying process. Like in the previous solution a hot air is
evaporating to the atmosphere.
|
Next solution
is a system, which causes that 90% of the air mass circulates
in the closed circulation. It is caused by a system with covers
that automatically close inlets and open the connection of a
demister ventilator with moat. A ventilator sucks in a previously
warmed air from a spray booth and again directs it to the spray
booth through the heat exchanger where the temperature falls
are suplemented. A cover that closes an inlet is specially leaky
to assure 10% of fresh air that is necessary for the dry process.
Until recently while this phaze an extracting ventilator was
off and 10% of the air excess were gravitationally excreted.
Directives of the EU has changed in this range and now to help
in excreting 10% of this air an extracting ventilator must work
also in the drying phase. |
Which
solution is the best for our customer? Lets use an example
again. Lets imagine that we drive a car with 4 people. There
is a winter and it is freezing outside. We drive several kilometers
and the engine achieved a proper temperature. The driver put
on the heating and the ventilator on the lowest revolution.
Will people sitting in the back feel warm? After what time?
And what will happen if a ventilator will be on the highest
revolution? Will the heat appear faster?
Spray booths are much more technically comlicated, equipped
in the electronic steering systems can also have an additional
working functions:
- ventilation phase, after a spraying phase
- chilling phase that turns on automatically after the drying
process
- special saving thermal energy system, which switch the spray
booth automatically into a recirculation phase in case we stop
the spraying process.
- Damages visualization system that is given in the form of
codes on the controller
- Possibility of installing completely automatic hypertension
regulation that is in the spray booth. That means to ensure
always the same air flow speed.
|
Let us
go back at the end to the main point of the spray booth that
is ventilation and heating unit called a generator or an aggregate. |
Producers
use as always different solutions based on technical possibilities
and mostly costs of production. In most of cases this kind of
generator is built as a self-supporting construction made from
steel sheet metal addequately bended to achieve a space profiles,
connected on the place of assembly by rivets or sheet metal
selt drilling screws and fulfilled by covers made from sheet
metal. Individual parts of construction are connected and form
a carrying structure for the heat exchanger, ventilator(s) and
additional equipment, like: recirculation cover (if occurs),
pneumatic motor operators, servo-motors, support for inlet and
launcher ventilation channels and other parts that may occur
in different constructions. |
 Producers
with a good reputation are companies with sereval years tradition
that do not specialize in making mass products. These companies
always make controls of assembly and the correctness of activity.
Their generators are built on the basie of solit steel constructions,
able to carry big load. It is delicered to the receiver in the
form of ready to work units, which incude all necessary elements
inside, like: ventilators, engines, covers, heating exchanger
etc. It brings several probles connected with transportation
and unloading of those devices.
The most essential parts of the generator are ventilators and
heating exchanger.
|
Heating
exchanger is necessary to "mediate" between
a burner flame and the air given to the spray chamber. A burner
placed on the exchanger's wall has a flame directed to the inside
of the exchanger, to the burning chamber. Fumes are piped away
to the fumes chiminey through the flame channels. The air is
given through the demister ventilator and heats from the exchanger.
Most of the producers make exchangers with a simple construction,
with fume channels made in the shape of vertical cracks place
side by side in one line over the burning chamber. In this kind
of the exchanger the air goes through those craks in not disturbing
way.
Other constructions place over the burning chamber a rounded
flame pipes placed in several lines. In this kind of exchangers
a flowing air must make a "snake" move. This cause
that the exchange surface is very big.
In heating systems of spray booths there are oil or gas burners.
It is good if burners are from a famous producer that could
make a proper tests of the product. Burner's power must be adjusted
to the required powoe of the heating system.
A consumption of the fuel depends on the burner's power and
on the work intensivity. That means that of there is cold outside,
a burner must work longer to make the air get a proper temperature.
If it works longer, it uses more fuel. That is why it is installed.
In spray booths heating systems one can come accross a following
oil and gas burners:
|
One
step - mostly used. The disadvantade is the big +/- difference,
even 3-4oC while a spraying phase. After setting
a temperature of 20oC) is sprays part of the car
in 17oC and in the minute another part of the car
in 23oC, A lacquer in this conditions will have a
different stick. |
Double
step - if they have installed a proper (eg. Spraytronic)
steering element, they are almost out of above mentioned faults.
Depending on the heat demand, first or both steps of the burner
are working.
Gas burners can also have so called a unit flame system. This
is a very expensive solution, but assuring a stable temperature.
|
Used in
spray booths ventilators are:
- One stream, placed directly
on the engine axle,
- Double stream , driven by a
transmission belt.
These are always ray ventilators.
One stream ventilators are good and cheap solution. They stand
a high ceiling filters pollution. They do not require any regulations,
have no rotary speed regulation possibility and also efficiency
because it is the same as the engine rotary.
|
Double stream ventilators are
driven by a belt transmission that lets to steer ventilator's
efficiency. It is important eg. Because of the big height of the
spray booth over the sea level. These ventilators have much highr
efficiency on 1 kW of the engine power.
We hope that this information will let you to orientate in all
the offers you get. We must understand that most of the producers
probably know how a spray both should be constructed to have a
high use virtues.
The other chapter is here the knowledge and reliability of the
dealer. Mostly these are hard working people with a hudge proffessional
knowledge that deserve a respect. However there appear people,
like in every enviroment, that base on the fast profit not on
the clients needs. Please ask for any technical details and you
will see who treats their clients serious.
|
|